Summer House's Kyle Cooke & Amanda Batula Spill on Season 9's Surprising Twists, Lindsay and Carl's Relationship, and How Rumors Shaped Filming - lulu

Credit: Ivan Apfel/Bravo

Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula revealed that Summer House had its first threesome amid filming on season nine during an appearance over the weekend.

While also dishing on the dynamic between exes Carl Radke, 39, and Lindsay Hubbard, 38, Kyle, 42, and Amanda, 33, teased what is to come on the new episodes. Plus, Kyle offered an update on where he stands with Lindsay and admitted that production on the upcoming season kicked off with the addressing of swirling rumors.

“We had our first threesome!” Kyle declared to PEOPLE at the Bravo Fan Fest 2024 in Miami.

“Not us! Not us!” Amanda clarified. “I did my fair share of sex on camera my first summer and I am done. I said if I’m going to have sex on camera, I’m going to make you pay for it on OnlyFans. I’m not putting it out there for free.”

“Yeah, we paid our dues. We’re done,” Kyle replied. “But yeah… Summer House had our first threesome.”

Then, after Amanda encouraged her husband not to “give it away,” Kyle said, “No one knows who, so there you go.”

According to Amanda, she and Kyle “had a fun summer” and felt that even Carl and Lindsay enjoyed themselves post-split.

“I’m really proud of them and how they were mostly able to take the high road,” Amanda noted. “They knew that they were signing up to co-exist under the same roof and they really embraced that.”

“It’s really nice to see them in that good place,” Kyle agreed. “I wouldn’t wish what they went through on anyone. I can’t even imagine, and we were pretty close to it. So props to them to coming out the other end.”

Although Carl and Lindsay are on very different journeys following their August 2023 breakup, with Carl focused on his new alcohol-free bar and Lindsay expecting a baby girl any day, Amanda said they both seem “really, really happy.”

“Lindsay got the family that she wanted and the guy that she really wanted, and Carl got the sober bar idea — which is so awesome — that he wanted. So they’re in the same place emotionally and fulfilled with what they’re doing right now,” she explained.

Meanwhile, in a series of posts shared by Bravo on Instagram, Kyle and Amanda were seen onstage at the Bravo event, where Kyle addressed a question about his relationship with Lindsay.

“Lindsay and I, we butt our heads quite a bit over the years, but like, we’re actually in a great place, which puts me in a weird place with Carl, but like, whatever,” Kyle shared. 

As for Amanda, she said that season nine was “one of [their] best summers yet.”

“It starts off rocky … but it was really good. Kyle behaved himself,” she teased. “For the first time ever, I think this is the first summer where we didn’t fight.”

While Kyle acknowledged that he and Amanda “had a lot of fun,” he added that rumors took a toll in their early moments in the Hamptons.

“Some of the rumors that were kind of brewing before the season started actually affected filming so that’s kind of how we kick off,” he revealed. “I’m glad we made a quick recovery because it was, when we go on the ups and downs, we were at like a low-low right before the season started, so for us to end up having a great summer meant a lot to me.”

“I actually think, overall, it was a really good season,” he went on. “There was good vibes. People got along … There’s, of course, a bunch of exes in the house, so we were riding high.”

Summer House season nine is expected to premiere on Bravo sometime in early 2025.