
Credit: Instagram
Lindsay Hubbard sparked rumors that she’s joining the cast of The Real Housewives of New York City as photos surfaced of her and Erin Lichy. Meanwhile, Erin, who revealed her pregnancy in November, addressed speculation that she secretly gave birth.
In 2023, Bravo replaced the entire cast of RHONY with younger stars. As the ratings declined, fans have suggested that Summer House’s Lindsay should join. Lindsay is around the same age as the cast, and she recently gave birth to her daughter Gemma.
On Instagram, Erin shared a photo of herself and Lindsay hanging out in a restaurant with their respective daughters.
“Girls day,” wrote Erin over the pic. “Gemma is edible.”

Image credit: @erindanalichy/Instagram
At some point, Erin shared a photo of her daughter Layla feeding a bottle of milk to Gemma, who is now three months old.

Image credit: @erindanalichy/Instagram via @lindshubbs/Instagram
The photo sparked speculation that Erin secretly gave birth. Addressing the theory, Erin wrote, “Guys I did not have the baby. Layla was feeding my [friend’s] 3 month old who I met for the first time!! I’m still massively pregnant.”

Image credit: @erindanalichy/Instagram
Last November, Erin addressed her pregnancy in an interview with PEOPLE.
“It feels like adding another act to the circus!” she said at the time. “Work and life have been so busy that I haven’t really had a chance to even think about how it’ll change things, but I think it will be pretty seamless to be honest. Three vs. four kids doesn’t seem so scary.”
“Mostly, I’m just looking forward to enjoying a Mezcalum cocktail and going out for a massive sushi dinner again!” Erin continued. She found out about the pregnancy as she got “super sensitive to smells around me.”
“I was out East with Abe and some friends … That’s when I knew — I thought, ‘Damn. Here we go again!’” she said, adding that the first 10 weeks of the pregnancy “were rough.”
“I was exhausted and nauseous all the time. Since then, not so bad!” said the star. “[I’ve been craving] cold drinks, Pinkberry and Greek yogurt, Italian food and French fries.”
“[We’ve] started floating around some name ideas,” she went on, “but we haven’t landed on anything just yet.”