Want more exclusive Bravo merchandise? Explore must-haves from your favorite shows at ShopbyBravo.com.
In an unaired moment from Part 3 of the The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 5 reunion, Mary Cosby stunned Andy Cohen when she let the Watch What Happens Live host know how she really felt about him.
Spoiler alert: It's so moving.
Toward the end of the episode, as seen in the extended version streaming now on Peacock, Andy led the women in an exercise: Each one would say something positive about another. This was in reference to the game the 'Wives tried to play during the cast trip to Puerto Vallarta.
Quick recap: During the last dinner in Mexico, Heather Gay attempted to get everyone to share the "worst" thing they had in their phone about someone else at the table. That way, there would be no more secrets between the ladies, which would hopefully relieve some of the tensions between them.
Unfortunately, the conversation grew too heated for some, which led a few to step away from the dinner early.
What does Mary Cosby think of Andy Cohen?
Andy's idea for the reunion was much more successful. But when Mary asked for him to compliment her, it wasn't for the reason you might be thinking. Instead of avoiding hearing what someone else in the group may have to say about her, the pastor was setting up an opportunity to do the same kind thing for Andy.
After the host finished saying what he found admirable about her, Mary asked, "Can I say something about you?"
"Sure," said Andy, who looked pleasantly surprised.
"I think that you are a star," she began. "I think that you are intelligent. You're smart. You're incredible. You're a beautiful father. You're inspirational. And you — I love how you support me. And I feel your support. When it was like the whole world was against me, you called me and reached out to me. You have something that no one ever has. I've never met anyone like Andy Cohen."
Andy was visibly moved by Mary's warm compliments, and replied with a sincere, "Thank you."
While this heartwarming scene didn't make it to air, you can find it in the extended version of the RHOSLC Season 5 reunion Part 3, which is streaming exclusively on Peacock.
During the reunion, Mary also spoke more about her family life, including her son, Robert Jr.
Where is Mary Cosby's son, Robert Jr., after The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 5?
During an episode of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City After Show, Mary told Angie Katsanevas that her son is doing well and living with his father, Mary's husband Robert Sr., in the family's Las Vegas home.
She explained that it was important for Robert Jr. to be "away from all the triggers" in Salt Lake City during his recovery.
In Part 1 of the RHOSLC Season 5 reunion, Mary revealed that despite her son's struggles, "he wanted to change" and move forward.
