Vanderpump Rules fans stunned as resurfaced Reddit posts accuse Brock Davies of juggling multiple women during Scheana Shay’s pregnancy, with bar sightings, gym flings and burner phone rumors painting a picture of serial betrayal - suong

“You think it was one woman? We saw him with three — and none of them were Scheana.”

In the days following the bombshell release of an excerpt from My Good Side — Scheana Shay’s raw and unfiltered memoir detailing how husband Brock Davies cheated on her while she was pregnant with their daughter — a new wave of speculation has erupted online. But this time, it’s not coming from tabloids or paparazzi.

It’s coming from Reddit.

Multiple threads have emerged on Bravo-centric subreddits and San Diego local forums, with former gym members, wellness influencers, and “bar regulars” in the Pacific Beach area alleging that Brock’s affair wasn’t a one-time mistake — but a recurring pattern.

“I used to go to F45 in San Diego. Brock flirted with women like it was his cardio,” one post read. “There was one girl he was always stretching. They’d leave in his truck. This was late 2020. We thought he was single.”

Another comment, timestamped back to early 2021 but recently re-shared, claimed:

“He came to Mavericks (bar) with a brunette one weekend and a totally different blonde the next. I asked a friend, and they said, ‘Oh, he’s Australian — it’s just his vibe.’”

Now, fans of Vanderpump Rules are questioning whether Scheana ever truly knew the scope of Brock’s betrayals — or if she, like many Bravo stars before her, believed in the illusion of a reformed man simply because the camera was rolling.

Adding fuel to the fire, a viral TikTok this week appeared to show a woman planting a kiss on Brock’s cheek in a dimly lit Vegas room, captioned with the cryptic line, “But there was a time.” The woman later confirmed in comments that the photo was from December 2015 — a timeline that predates his relationship with Scheana but raises eyebrows about a longstanding pattern of overlap.

While Scheana’s memoir confirms a single affair during her pregnancy in 2020, the emotional fallout is already messy — and fans are now suggesting it may get worse.

“If this man had a second phone, a burner, a gym network, and people covering for him,” one Redditor wrote, “you think it was just one woman? That’s delusion.”

Even more disturbingly, one local wellness blogger shared that she had received DMs warning her to “stay away from the guy who wears NOBULL shoes and says he’s in crypto” — later realizing the description matched Brock during his early San Diego days.

Insiders close to the Bravo universe are reportedly urging Scheana to brace herself for more women stepping forward, especially with the release of My Good Side set to launch nationwide July 22. One producer said off-record:

“There are whispers about at least two more women. Not all of them knew he was in a relationship — one reportedly thought she was the girlfriend.”

Scheana, who once famously stood by Brock when past details of his estrangement from his older children emerged, now faces the humiliating reality that her “second chance at love” may have been built on false intimacy, performative redemption, and spiritual bypassing.

“He told her he was afraid to be a father again,” one source familiar with the book’s uncut draft revealed. “But fear doesn’t excuse betrayal. Especially when it’s not once — but a pattern.”

As of now, both Scheana and Brock have remained silent on the Reddit allegations, and Bravo has declined to comment on whether the emerging claims will be addressed in any upcoming Vanderpump spinoff or special.

But as one Reddit user succinctly put it:

“Scheana wrote a memoir. He wrote a body count. And we’re just now reading the rest.”