Teddi Mellencamp's Controversial Halloween Costume: A Reference to the Horse Trainer Affair That Didn't Stand the Test of Time - lulu

   

Teddi Mellencamp’s Halloween costume “didn’t age well” amid news of her alleged affair.

Sources told Page Six on Wednesday that the “Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” alum cheated on her husband, Edwin Arroyave, with a married horse trainer.

The man, whom the Daily Mail identified as Simon Schroeder, has allegedly been training her horse, Toad — which is the animal Mellencamp, 43, dressed up as for Halloween.

Teddi Mellencamp via Instagram in October

Teddi Mellencamp’s Halloween costume referenced her alleged affair with Simon Schroeder.teddimellencamp/Instagram

Teddi Mellencamp via Instagram in December 2023

The Bravolebrity dressed up as a toad.teddimellencamp/Instagram

Teddi Mellencamp via Instagram

Toad is the name of her horse trained by the man she allegedly cheated with.teddimellencamp/Instagram

The former reality star posed in her blue onesie in an Instagram carousel featuring daughter Slate, 12, son Cruz, 10, and daughter Dove, 4, last month.

“A toad, a pumpkin, Ariel, and… a zombie footballer?!” she captioned the slideshow. “This definitely ain’t Disney! What are you naming this Halloween motley crew?”

Mellencamp’s followers have returned to the comments section since she and Schroeder made headlines to troll her.

Simon Schroeder

He has been identified as Simon Schroeder.Instagram/@simonschroeder

Simon Schroeder and Karli Postel

Schroeder was married to Mellencamp’s friend Karli Postel.Instagram/Karli Postel

“I need a pic of you dressed as a toad with Toad  ,” one social media user wrote.

Another added, “This doesn’t age well dressing up as Toad  when you f’ed Toads trainer.”

Mellencamp filed for divorce fr

Simon Schroeder via Instagram

He has yet to comment on the allegations.Instagram/@simonschroeder

Teddi Mellencamp and Edwin Arroyave via Instagram

The scandal came to light two weeks after Mellencamp filed for divorce from Edwin Arroyave.Instagram/@teddimellencamp

At the time, the Bravolebrity requested primary custody of their children.

Arroyave, who is also the father of a 15-year-old daughter named Isabella from a previous relationship, responded by filing for joint legal and physical custody.

This week, “Real Housewives of Orange County” alum Kelly Dodd claimed via Instagram that Mellencamp “cheated” and called her a “douchebag.”

Teddi Mellencamp and Edwin Arroyave via Instagram

The duo have been married for 13 years.Instagram/edwinarroyaveofficial

Teddi Mellencamp, Edwin Arroyave and kids via Instagram

They share three children.teddimellencamp/Instagram

Page Six subsequently reported that Schroeder’s wife is Mellencamp’s pal Karli Postel.

“Mellencamp and Schroeder were in Florida together for an equestrian event while Postel was in California in labor with their second child,” the insider alleged.

Mellencamp, Arroyave, Schroeder and Postel have yet to respond to Page Six’s request for comment.