Southern Charm’s Shep Rose never seemed to be on quite the same page as Sienna Evans about their relationship, making it all the more appropriate that he said their breakup felt “like a death by a thousand paper cuts" on Season 10, Episode 13.
As Shep revealed on the Southern Charm After Show, though, cameras didn’t show that Sienna had an emotional reaction, too.
After removing Sienna from the “firing squad” — aka his fellow Southern Charmers — at the dinner table during the episode, Shep initiated another beachside breakup conversation. “She goes, ‘I’m not choosing happiness’ and started crying,” Shep recalled to Austen Kroll in the above After Show clip. “And I was like, ‘Why wouldn’t you choose happiness?’”
When Austen questioned what that even meant, Shep replied, “That means, ‘I’m being calculated and opportunistic, and feelings be damned.’”