Now’s the Time for the Rangers to Consider a Bold Alexis Lafrenière Trade
Since being selected first overall in the 2020 NHL Draft, Alexis Lafrenière has been at the center of high expectations. The New York Rangers envisioned him as a future superstar, a game-changing forward who could elevate the franchise. However, after several seasons of development, the 22-year-old winger has yet to fully break out into the elite player many anticipated. While he has shown flashes of brilliance, his inconsistency and struggles to secure a top-line role have raised questions about his long-term fit in New York.
Now, with the Rangers aiming for a deep playoff run and championship aspirations at their peak, it may be time for the organization to make a bold move—trading Alexis Lafrenière while his value is still high.
The Case for Trading Lafrenière
While Lafrenière has improved in certain aspects of his game, he remains somewhat of an enigma. He has undeniable talent, strong offensive instincts, and the ability to play with physicality, but his production has not reached the level expected of a former first-overall pick. In a team loaded with offensive weapons like Artemi Panarin, Mika Zibanejad, and Chris Kreider, Lafrenière has struggled to carve out a consistent role on the top lines.
There are several key reasons why trading him now could benefit the Rangers:
-
Maximizing Trade Value: Lafrenière’s stock remains solid because of his pedigree, age, and potential. Many teams would be willing to take a gamble on a young, high-upside forward who may thrive in a new environment. The Rangers could capitalize on his value by acquiring a player who better fits their current needs.
-
Addressing Immediate Needs: The Rangers are in win-now mode, with their core players at or near their prime. However, there are still gaps in the lineup—whether on defense, center depth, or even goaltending insurance. Moving Lafrenière could bring in a proven top-six forward, a reliable defenseman, or a high-quality center to solidify the team’s depth.
-
Cap Considerations: With several big contracts already on the books, including Panarin, Zibanejad, Adam Fox, and Igor Shesterkin, the Rangers need to be mindful of cap space. Lafrenière is currently on a bridge deal, but his next contract could be more expensive. Trading him now could help the team manage future cap constraints while adding a cost-effective asset in return.
-
Coaching and System Fit: Under head coach Peter Laviolette, the Rangers play a structured, defense-first system that may not be the best fit for Lafrenière’s game. If he isn’t going to receive top-line minutes and power-play time, it might be better for both parties to move on.
Potential Trade Destinations
If the Rangers were to explore a Lafrenière trade, several teams could be interested. Here are some potential destinations and trade scenarios:
-
Montreal Canadiens: As a native of Quebec, Lafrenière would be an instant fan favorite in Montreal. The Canadiens are rebuilding and could offer a package involving a young center (such as Kirby Dach or a top prospect) to the Rangers.
-
Chicago Blackhawks: Pairing Lafrenière with Connor Bedard could be an intriguing option for the Blackhawks as they continue their rebuild. Chicago has the cap space and assets to make a move.
-
Ottawa Senators: The Senators have a surplus of young forwards and might be willing to swap talent to balance their roster. A package involving a young defenseman could be enticing for the Rangers.
-
Calgary Flames: The Flames have multiple players rumored to be on the trade block, including Noah Hanifin and Elias Lindholm. If the Rangers want to strengthen their blue line or center depth, Calgary could be a strong trade partner.
What Would the Rangers Look for in Return?
If the Rangers do trade Lafrenière, they will likely target:
- A top-six forward who can contribute immediately
- A young center to solidify their depth
- A defenseman with size and skill
- Draft picks and prospects to replenish their future assets
Given the team’s championship window, the focus should be on acquiring a player who can make an impact now rather than future draft picks or long-term projects.
Conclusion
Trading Alexis Lafrenière is a difficult decision, but it’s one the Rangers must at least consider. While he still has room to grow, the team needs to focus on maximizing their current roster’s potential. If the right deal presents itself—one that improves the team’s chances of winning a Stanley Cup—it would be wise for the Rangers to pull the trigger.
The Lafrenière era in New York may not have lived up to expectations, but a fresh start elsewhere could be beneficial for both the player and the team. With the trade deadline approaching, the Rangers should explore all options and determine whether now is the time to make a bold move.
