Michelle Saniei and Aaron Nosler of The Valley Part Ways After a Year: Unpacking Their Split and Michelle's Next Moves - lulu

Credit: Bravo

Michelle Saniei and Aaron Nosler have called it quits after one year of dating.

After Michelle, 36, sparked rumors of a split earlier this week after unfollowing Aaron and scrubbing his photos from her Instagram page, a couple of insiders have confirmed that The Valley stars have parted ways ahead of production on season three, which is expected to begin soon.

“[Michelle] is in the process of moving out” of Aaron’s home, an insider confirmed to Us Weekly on July 24, as a second source said Michelle was “focusing on her daughter [five-year-old Isabella], work, and taking care of herself as she navigates this new chapter in her life.”

Throughout the second season of The Valley, Michelle and Aaron’s romance, and when it truly began, was pulled into question as some suspected there was an overlap with her marriage to Jesse Lally, 45, whom she split from in early 2024. However, Michelle maintained that her relationship with Aaron was strictly platonic until after her and Jesse’s breakup.

Ahead of the season two premiere, Michelle noted that filming was different from how it was during season one since she had “somebody very supportive” at her side.

“I’m super excited to show the new chapter of my life and my boyfriend Aaron. I feel like myself. We’re going to see the real me and how happy I am,” she gushed to Us Weekly at the time. 

Meanwhile, in the same interview, Aaron noted, “I tried to help and bring a positive light into it.”

Michelle and Aaron’s split comes just months after she appeared on an episode of Watch What Happens Live, where she spoke of their potential plans to wed.

“I definitely can see that happening,” she stated. “I hope for the best, and we’re very compatible and very good with one another. We rarely fight, and he’s amazing with Isabella too.”

The Valley season two reunion begins airing Tuesday, July 29, at 8/7c on Bravo.