Lindsay Hubbard may have officially confirmed her split from Turner Kufe just three months ago, but fans aren’t so sure the couple’s love story is truly over. The Summer House alum, 37, was spotted leaving a pediatrician's office in Tribeca last week with Turner by her side and their daughter, Gemma Britt Kufe, bundled in her arms. But it wasn’t just the united front that caught attention—it was the quiet, almost instinctive moment when Turner leaned in and kissed Lindsay on the forehead as they loaded the baby into the car. One bystander said the gesture didn’t feel like two exes playing nice, but rather “two people who never actually let go.”
The pair, who welcomed their first child in December 2024, announced their “amicable split” earlier this spring, citing the pressures of new parenthood and different communication styles. Yet in the weeks since, they've remained visibly connected—sharing childcare duties, exchanging inside jokes on Instagram, and even co-hosting a “Newborn Survival” livestream just last month. At one point during that stream, Lindsay accidentally referred to Turner as “my partner” before quickly correcting to “co-parent.” The moment was subtle, but not lost on the fans, who flooded the comments with theories of a soft reconciliation.
A source close to the couple tells DailyMail.com that while Lindsay and Turner are not officially back together, “they’re basically doing everything a couple would—minus the public label.” The source adds: “They sleep under the same roof half the week, they cook together, they take turns on baby night duty. Lindsay still hasn’t removed Turner’s toiletries from her bathroom, and Turner still shows up with flowers and snacks. They just don’t want to admit to anyone—including themselves—that they’re still in it.”
What’s more telling, insiders say, is how fiercely private they’ve become. Friends claim that Lindsay has asked her inner circle not to tag her in any posts involving Turner and has repeatedly declined to clarify their status during podcast interviews. “She says she doesn’t owe anyone a label right now, that she’s focused on her baby—but the truth is, there’s a fear that if they call it something again, it could fall apart again,” a source reveals.
Meanwhile, Turner has remained relatively quiet on social media, but fans noted he recently deleted his Hinge profile and liked a comment calling Lindsay “the realest woman in the Bravo universe.” And while he’s made appearances at Summer House-adjacent gatherings, sources say he often leaves early to “relieve Lindsay from night duty.”
Those closest to the couple say the bond formed during pregnancy and the early newborn months has proven harder to sever than either expected. “They tried to create distance, but the baby just pulled them closer again. It’s not just co-parenting—it’s co-existing,” the insider adds.
Whether they’ll publicly reunite or continue orbiting each other in this intimate gray area remains to be seen. But if forehead kisses, shared grocery hauls, and 3 a.m. bottle shifts say anything—it’s that this so-called breakup might be more of a pause than a full stop. And fans? They’re already rooting for a Part Two.