Andy Cohen confirmed there is X-rated evidence of his relationship with ex-boyfriend John Hill somewhere out there.
Hill brought up the pair’s old sex during Tuesday’s “Watch What Happens Live” episode while listing “the top five things” Cohen should do in 2025.
While the former Broadway star jokingly said he’d like to see Cohen “get tits” and “learn how to read,” his third bullet point took the audience — and Cohen — by surprise.
“Release our sex tape from 2003,” Hill, 46, said as the Bravo executive, 56, burst into laughter.
Andy Cohen confirmed he and ex John Hill made a sex tape.Watch What Happens Live/Bravo
Hill made the shocking confession on Tuesday’s episode of “Watch What Happens Live.”Watch What Happens Live/Bravo
The admission shocked fellow guests Racquel Chevremont and Erika Jayne, who quipped “Wait, I kind of want to see it? Is it fun?”
However, when asked if they could “pull it up,” Cohen revealed he didn’t know where the tape was.
“You know what, I think there is one,” Cohen admitted. “But the format, it’s on some janky format.”
“It’s bad,” Hill added.
Hill claimed they made the tape in 2003.Watch What Happens Live/Bravo
The 46-year-old jokingly encouraged Cohen to “release” the video.Watch What Happens Live/Bravo
Despite the “Housewives”‘s pleas, Cohen said he was “glad” it would be nearly impossible to “transfer” the tape and make it watchable.
Cohen and Hill dated for three years in the early 2000s before ultimately deciding they were better off as friends.
During an old episode of “WWHL,” the media mogul explained that he and Hill were simply “in different places in our lives.”
Hill reiterated Cohen’s comments during a 2020 podcast appearance, explaining that he and the producer were in different phases of their careers.
The Bravo exec said it would be impossible to find and convert the tape.Watch What Happens Live/Bravo
“It’s bad,” the former Broadway star joked.Charles Sykes/Bravo via Getty Images
“It was heartbreaking and super sad,” he said on the “Hot Takes and Deep Dives” podcast. “But like any breakup … it was time to break up.”
The producer noted that he was pushing 30 and ready for a career change, which took him to Los Angeles, while Cohen remained in New York City and “moved up” in the network ranks.
“We always had an intimate connection. We always had an emotional, vulnerable — like an honest, open relationship,” he continued.
“We were great together and we always made each other laugh … but we grew apart in terms of boyfriendness. We had the friendship, we have the love but the boyfriend part was kind of fading.”
The exes dated for three years in the early 2000s.NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images
They have remained great friends and coworkers despite their failed relationship.NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images
However, the pair have remained close in the two decades since their split, collaborating on their SiriusXM show, “Radio Andy” and “WWHL,” where Hill is credited as a producer.
The former “Hairspray” star joked about their working relationship when it came to his fourth bullet point.
“Give your radio co-host the raise he deserves,” Hill said, to which Cohen jokingly replied, “Everyone is doing really well.”
