Andy Cohen Drops Bombshell: Confirms Raunchy Sex Tape with Ex-Boyfriend John Hill

Yes, Andy Cohen made a sex tape with his ex-boyfriend, John Hill. No, you aren’t ever going to see it. The Watch What Happens Live feels pretty confident about that.

Andy and John made the surprising confession about their filmed sexcapade during a recent episode of Watch What Happens Live. The admission surprised viewers, but now, Andy is just as shocked by the response.

Andy Cohen and John Hill’s not-so-secret home video

If you’re a big fan of Andy, then you know John. Not only is he Andy’s ex-boyfriend from the early aughts, but he’s also his co-host on Sirius XM’s Andy Cohen Live.

On WWHL, John popped up as a bartender and listed five things Andy should do in the New Year. John’s suggestions were all ridiculous. For example, he suggested that Andy get rid of his kids.

“Number Four: Finally learn to read,” John joked

He continued, “Release our sex tape from 2003,” which got a huge reaction from everyone in the room. Erika Jayne was a guest that night and immediately said she wanted to see it with her own eyes. Andy’s lawyers probably squirmed at that comment.

“You know what, I think there is one,” Andy confessed. “But the format, it’s on some janky format.”

John agreed that it was bad, and the two moved on with the rest of the New Year’s list. However, that moment came back to haunt them when People published an article about the sex tape. During Andy and John’s next radio broadcast, they roasted the outlet for taking the story so seriously.

“While we were going to break, my publicist sent an article from People Magazine. People, which is huge,” Andy said, before reading the outlet’s racy headline.

Immediately, he and John started to explain that the sex tape wasn’t anything that exciting. It doesn’t sound like we’re missing out on anything. It’s not a must-see.

“It sounds worse than it is,” John explained. “It’s not like one of us has it. It’s been destroyed. I think.”

The exes explained that it was more of a “joke” between them. They did it right around the same time a “huge celebrity” had a sex tape released. Ultimately, the whole thing seems a lot less steamy than the headline suggests.

Andy concluded, “I just can’t believe there’s that headline on People Magazine. I mean, my family’s gonna see that.”

Watch What Happens Live airs on Bravo Sunday through Thursday.